Billy Herrington had used 4 known aliases as well, early in during his career.
- Billy used his very first alias Stallion, when he performed for ProMuscle Media for Naked Muscle 3.
- Billy used the alias Billy Harrington, when he performed for MuscleGods Productions for Dark Pursuit, though this may had been a spelling error.
- Billy used the alias Billy Marcus for only three Can-Am Productions films: Worship: Muscle Fantasies 1, Wrestlers: Muscle Fantasies 2, and Maxon vs. Marcus.
- Billy used the alias Jake Stevens in his only straight pornographic film appearance for Jet Set Productions for Extreme Mat Fights.